Ignorance, lack of awareness, resistance to change, false feminism and a flawed justice system are all contributing towards India becoming the rape capital of the civilized world
December 8, 2019 Leave a comment
India becoming the rape capital of the civilized world (if one such exists at all) is a stark reality on the face of every Indian. The most recent ones that have shaken the country are the brutal rape and murder of a veterinarian while a rape survivor who complained against her rapists who in turn has influential connections in the society have burnt her alive. The country woke up finally to crimes against women with the Nirbhaya case in 2012 but has a shaken and stirred country been able to stop such crimes? Clearly not.
If we take a broad look at crimes and especially against women, 98-99% are planned ones and only 1-2% are opportunistic ones. Nirbhaya was an opportunistic one and according to how her male friend who was with her had recounted the incident, it probably may not have happened if she hadn’t turned aggressive when the perpetrators of the crime were taunting and making fun of him. If he had felt offended at them, he would have had responded. But why didn’t he? I have traveled with women friends and colleagues at night in cities and I have always made sure I do not get into any nasty situations because if the situation worsens, the harm would invariably come to the women with me. Worse than that would be if a crowd forms and the first question that would pop up is “What is she doing with him at night?”. This is how it is in India and no amount of reasoning with a crowd will help diffuse the situation. The woman with me will be whom the crowd will target. So what would I do in such a case? Puff up my manly ego or keep it down and let the situation melt away? That’s what Nirbhaya’s friend was most probably trying to do. When I say she shouldn’t have had become aggressive is because it makes no sense for a woman to engage with unknown men at the level of bus drivers and bus cleaners in the dead of the night inside a moving bus which had tinted glass all over it.
Coming back to the recent crime, the police report on the veterinarian’s ghastly murder is bizarre. The perpetrators had apparently deflated her bike’s tire and waited for her to return to pounce on her. How were they so sure she would return and that too alone? How were they so sure they could lure her with the deflated tire and overpower her? What if she had not returned that night to take the bike at all? What if she had returned with a friend in the cab? What if she had dialed the police instead of her friend? I can give 10 scenarios how the crime could not have happened. The perpetrators have been ferrying goods through the toll booth time and again and lorry drivers take breaks at toll booths which can be observed at all booths. She was travelling by the same toll for probably a couple of years every day so it is obvious that more than one person may have noticed her albeit casually. It is also obvious that the perpetrators had observed not just her travel routine but also sketched out her behavior and personality. People with criminal mindset are adept at doing this and this is why mindset of criminals are even studied in detail. It could also be possible that she may have left her bike at the booth, traveled by cab and then returned to take the bike in the past as well. 4 men see a woman leave her bike and take a cab and decide to deflate her tire to lure her into raping and killing her when she returns to take her bike is too random to be even accepted as an opportunistic crime. So why are the police not talking about all of this? Maybe because it will drive fear into every man’s and woman’s heart and society will go into meltdown because this is the real India after it turns dark.
I stay near a supermarket store and I am quite friendly with all the women working there. Even before becoming friendly with them, I used to see them in the morning and evening at a particular time every day when they go to work and leave the supermarket after work. My point here is, people observe others, purposefully and inadvertently if there is a particular routine. Purposefully would be with an objective and we will know it only when it unravels. Women need to understand this fact clearly and they need to be observant about people and their surroundings but they are mostly not with a good reason.
Women are sticklers to routines and schedules and they fall into their comfort zones very easily. My mom sleeps by 9 at night, wakes up (with an alarm) at 4:30 in the morning, goes for her bath at 10:30 in the morning and 6 in the evening and so on. She does everything at definite time periods which irks my dad to no end. When I am away from home, I know exactly what she will be doing at what time. This is also a pain point for women because men are hardly organized this way and women have no clue what their men are doing at any point of time. This is why when wives and girlfriends call their husbands and boyfriends their first question invariably would be “Where are you?” or “What are you doing?” which in turn irritates men because they do random things that women with their organized mindset will never understand.
All of this is fine for a housewife like my mother and some of my friends I know but being organized quickly becomes a disadvantage when women step out especially in India. Consider the example of school going girls especially in suburban and rural India. From the time of high school, many of them start getting stalked by boys and men in their neighborhood. This in turn pushes them into an even stricter routine, like walking on a certain road with selected friends at a certain time when going and returning from school. The stalkers get to understand their routine clearly and they wait for the time when the girls would be walking alone to molest or abuse her. Men lose interest quickly at observing women if they cannot find a routine or pattern to their lifestyle.
What I am trying to throw light upon is the fact that women need to consciously change their mindset and be extremely observant of their surroundings. Whether they like it or not and be it in India or anywhere else, women will be observed by men and especially if they are following any routines in their activities outside. There is a clear difference between fear and awareness to potential threats. Women need not fear but they need to be aware of who and what circumstances can become threatening to them. The biggest problem they face is, because of their organized mindset and lesser awareness of their surroundings, a sudden attack seems completely random to them and paralyses their mind. This delay in reacting is what helps men subdue and control them.
This, in no way means the onus of changing the rape culture is on the women. Though the mindset of men towards women needs a complete makeover, it makes no sense to expect men to change their ways in a small time frame especially since society has been male dominated for thousands of years and even education became accessible to women only in the last 100 years. In every animal in nature there is a fine balance between the responsibilities shared by males and females to ensure that they are able to procreate and their species continues to be a dominant one. Because we moved away from being part of the nature’s food chain which keeps the population of every species under control through the predator-prey relationship, our population has exploded to the point where we no longer need to procreate. The balance between male and female that exists in nature is no longer present in us. Men and women are in the process of evolution to coexist in the changing societal conditions. We have been always resistant to changes which is why men have been unwilling to share their dominion with women and which I believe is the fundamental reason why more women are getting targeted because of the patriarchal nature of Indian society.
When I wrote that women need to become smarter and wiser in the changing world to tackle men in an article for the online content platform I have been writing for the past 2 years, they deleted my article mentioning that they find my views unacceptable. It is this burgeoning bubble of false feminism that is misleading women into believing that the mindset of men has to and will change for them immediately. I was raised up by my grandmother who made it mandatory for me to not go out without reason, not speak to people without reason, do not come in front of visitors at home, do not ask questions to elders and be back at home before 7 in the evening unless I was in the office. She was not educated but knew how to fix even electric wires and fuses and had no hesitation in calling out her husband and sons if they were doing something wrong. She would have had gobbled up these so called feminists as snacks along with her evening tea.
When feminists are clamoring that women need not change, then why is there so much promotion for girls from school to learn martial arts? Why are more teenage girls taking up classes for self protection? Why are women police officers conducting sessions for girl students on self defense? Why do more and more women use mobile phones with some sort of apps that can send out panic alerts to their near ones if they are in trouble? Whether women like it or not, the society has been man’s domain for all these years and there will be no 180 degree flip in a few years. Society is at the cross roads of evolution as it changes to accept women in the same breath as men. But this will take time and there are no magic wands to make it happen right now.
So why has a shaken and stirred India not being able to stop violent crimes against women after Nirbhaya? Because I believe the magnitude of punishment is not coherent with the magnitude of the crimes. The four accused in the crime against the veterinarian have been gunned down by the police which in turn has only raised more questions. Were they treated as accused based only on their confession? Was the crime scene investigation completed and DNA tests conducted to establish that they were the ones who had committed the crime before they were shot to death? These details would have been required to be presented in court for their prosecution. If they were indeed trying to escape according to the police, why were they shot to death rather than shot to immobilize and capture them? While I do not believe that such criminals should be painfully taken through the process of law and fed with taxpayer’s money in jails, instant death with bullets was not what they deserved for the horrific torture they unleashed on their victim. In all probability, it does look like they were taken down for instant gratification of the people who were demanding their execution.
More brutal the crime more brutal should be the punishment. The justice system India follows is largely meant for an organized and mature society and not to deal with such horrific crimes and criminals. The ones who indulge in these crimes have no fear of law, police and jails. Punishment is meant to reform the ones who commit crimes, but many of them, especially the ones who commit crimes against women choose not to reform themselves. Once they serve their time in prison and are let go, they know they will be treated as outcasts in the society and they can step fully into the world of crime and abuse more women. I firmly believe fear of brutal punishment is the only deterrent that can effectively stop men from committing such crimes on women. I know many people will not agree with me but the sooner we accept that Indian society is far from being mature the better we will be able to curb these crimes.